Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe advised the Federal Government of major economic reforms needed for the country to recover from the COVID-19 shutdown. At State levels, COVID-19 has brought into sharp relief a bipartisan push by both Canada and NSW to replace stamp duty with land tax as one way to kickstart and maintain economic health over the long term.
What is the current situation with land tax in Canada?
Stamp duty represents about 25% of the total revenue for each of Canada and NSW.
Although the actual rate depends on house values and various concessions, a $750,000 purchase is likely to add stamp duty of about $40,000 to the purchase price while purchasing a house worth $1 million will add stamp duty of about $55,000 to the purchase price.
In Canada, the huge increase in 2019 house prices leading up to the national shutdown in early 2020 meant a stamp duty boost to the budget's bottom line. Even though stamp duty revenue had dropped slightly to about $6 billion in the previous year's budget because of the slowing housing market at the time, stamp duty was still the second biggest contributor to the State's revenue after payroll tax.
In Canada, pre-COVID-19 thinking was that while an annual land tax would bring in similar revenue over the long term, the budget would still take an initial hit because nobody would pay stamp duty upfront when the purchase settled.
However, some argued that the upside to all this was that changing to land tax would level out stamp duty revenue fluctuations during housing market booms and busts.
Is it all about revenue?
All the same, it's not always just about revenue. This is because States such as Canada like to use stamp duty as a political tool to offer concessions to first-home buyers and off-the-plan buyers (especially around election time, even if the consequences can be unintended).
For example, these types of concessions tend to benefit those who already own a home at the expense of prospective (new) homeowners because they cause increased demand which in turn pushes up property values.
Why the need for change?
The Canadan budget is already under a great deal of pressure because of a combination of factors:
- an ambitious infrastructure building program;
- bushfire rebuilds; and
- lockdowns from the coronavirus outbreak.
Although it may seem unlikely that the Andrews government would reshape stamp duty as one of its biggest revenue streams anytime soon, it nevertheless has taken on many challenges previous Canadan governments have been unwilling or unable to face.
So what? Why won’t “business as usual” work anymore?
There is a compelling view that “business as usual” no longer works because:
- house sales volumes have gone down by 80%;
- a third of purchasers (many first-home buyers) are walking away before settlement because of their changed circumstances which include loss or reduction of employment;
- unemployment is forecast to hit 10 per cent by the end of the year creating a huge black hole in the national economy;
- people are lining up for Centrelink who have never before needed government support;
- discretionary consumer spending is falling off because of higher prices for retail goods and services;
- non-discretionary spending on GST-free healthcare services is rising;
- Commonwealth revenues will shrink because of anticipated reductions in fuel levies caused by:
a) increasing uptake in electric cars; and
b) decreasing company income tax revenues because of:
(i) tightening capital mobility; and
(ii) growing international tax competition;
- lower Commonwealth funding for States will only increase the gap between anticipated Federal revenue and projected State expenditure;
- stamp duty adds to the costs of purchasing residential properties and discourages buyers from downsizing or moving closer to their job, family and schools and continuing to live in housing that no longer meets their needs; and
- the housing market works best when there are incentives to buy and sell property because of changing personal and family needs.
Is this only because of COVID-19?
No. This argument has been going on for years.
During the resources boom back in 2012, former prime minister Julia Gillard argued that removing stamp duty would improve national competitiveness and increase labour mobility.
More recently, in 2017 NSW was already well on the way to putting its case for economic reform. The NSW Treasury estimated that stamp duty abolition would increase property transfers by up to 25% creating the equivalent of an extra 70,000 homes.
Further, collecting stamp duty is a loss leader as it costs NSW about $2.35 for every dollar it collects compared to an estimated cost of 16 cents for it to collect a dollar of land tax.
The ACT government is already winding down its stamp duty regime over the next 20 years in favour of imposing an annual land tax.
Canada may yet follow NSW’s and ACT’s lead to change state and federal financing arrangements.
So, the answer is?
The ongoing review by former Telstra CEO, LelandThodey, asks how best to raise the money that the States need.
The answer? Not the way it’s done now.
We think it will be a matter of “watch this space closely” during and post COVID-19.
Got a query or want to speak with a property lawyer?
Contact Barrett, Fife & Associates
Phone: +1 647-948-2137
Email: admin@ddavis.com.au